Utilitarianism and Its Ethical Challenges in Victorian Reform

Utilitarianism emerged in the Victorian era as a guiding principle for social reform, often prioritizing the greatest good over individual rights. The Poor Law Amendment Act of 1834 exemplifies this tension, as it aimed to optimize welfare at the expense of the poor's basic needs. The harsh realities of Victorian slums reveal the human cost of these policies, highlighting the stark contrast between progress and suffering. A critical examination of utilitarian ethics through contrasting essays showcases the ongoing debate around its moral implications.

1. Read
   Utilitarianism · Wikipedia

   Defines utilitarianism as a theory that prescribes actions maximizing happiness for all affected individuals, emphasizing the greatest good for the greatest number. Jeremy Bentham, its founder, describes utility in terms of pleasure, happiness, and the prevention of harm.

2. Read
   Poor Law Amendment Act 1834 · Wikipedia

   Describes the Poor Law Amendment Act 1834 as legislation that denied the poor the right to subsistence, fundamentally altering the poverty relief system in England and Wales. The Act emerged from the 1832 Royal Commission, which included prominent figures like Edwin Chadwick.

3. Watch
   

   The Harsh Reality Of Victorian London Slums · YouTube

   Exposes the brutal conditions of Victorian London slums, revealing the stark contrasts between progress and squalor faced by millions. The documentary highlights the public health crisis exemplified by the 'Great Stink' and the devastating impact of workhouses on families.

4. Book
   

   Utilitarianism: For and Against · Bookshop.org

   Presents two essays on utilitarianism from opposing perspectives, with J.J.C. Smart advocating for a modern interpretation of classical utilitarianism. Bernard Williams counters by questioning the moral implications of prioritizing collective happiness over individual rights.

The selected pieces trace the development of utilitarianism and its application to Victorian social policy, illustrating the ethical conflicts that arose. Beginning with a foundational overview of utilitarianism, the curation moves to a specific legislative example, the Poor Law Amendment Act, which reflects its principles in action. A documentary then provides a visceral depiction of the consequences of these policies on the lives of the poor, setting the stage for a philosophical debate. Finally, the contrasting essays in the anchor piece provoke deeper reflection on the merits and drawbacks of utilitarianism.

Book links are Bookshop.org affiliate links. Curiate may earn a commission on purchases, at no extra cost to you — Bookshop.org also gives a share to independent bookshops.